Two-Year Lookback
Independent site, not affiliated with any government agency. Figures come from CMS and SSA publications, cited on each page.

IRMAA appeal or new determination: which to ask for

If you think your IRMAA is wrong or no longer fair, Social Security has two routes. A new initial determination recalculates IRMAA from better or newer information. A reconsideration is a formal appeal of the decision. Social Security's own manual says a new determination usually gets the same result as an appeal, so start by checking whether you qualify for one.

Pick the route that fits

What to ask for, by situation
Your situationAsk forWhat to bring
Retirement, less work, marriage, divorce, a spouse's death, or another of the eight life-changing events lowered your incomeNew initial determination (Form SSA-44)Proof of the event and your newer MAGI (return or estimate). SSA-44 helper
You amended the tax return Social Security usedNew initial determinationThe amended return and the IRS receipt letter, or an IRS transcript (POMS HI 01120.045)
The IRS data is wrongGet the IRS to correct it first, then a new initial determinationThe IRS letter showing the correction. IRS: 1-800-829-1040 (POMS HI 01120.050)
Social Security used your return from three years back and the two-year-back return is lowerNew initial determinationA copy of the more recent return (POMS HI 01120.055)
You filed separately but lived apart from your spouse all yearNew initial determinationA signed statement that you lived apart, under penalty of perjury (POMS HI 01120.060)
You disagree with the decision for another reason, or a new determination was deniedReconsideration (appeal)Form SSA-561, Request for Reconsideration, and any evidence

Routes from POMS HI 01120.001, Overview of New Initial Determinations.

You can ask for both at once. If your situation is not in the table, such as a Roth conversion or a large capital gain, you can still appeal. Social Security's manual treats those as non-qualifying events, so the appeal is unlikely to change the amount.

Deadlines

  • Reconsideration: within 60 days of receiving the IRMAA notice. Social Security assumes you received it 5 days after the date on the notice unless you show otherwise. Late requests need "good cause" (POMS HI 01140.001).
  • Life-changing event: any time after the event and the drop in income. Decisions are not backdated to earlier premium years, except for an event in October to December reported by March 31 (POMS HI 01120.005).
  • Amended return: within three calendar years after the close of the tax year it amends (POMS HI 01120.045).
  • Married filing separately, lived apart: from the date of the IRMAA notice until the end of that premium year (POMS HI 01120.060).

Missed the 60 days because Social Security steered you to a new determination, which was then denied? Its manual says that counts as good cause, so you can still appeal (POMS HI 01140.005).

The appeal levels

  1. Reconsideration by Social Security.
  2. A hearing before an administrative law judge in the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals (part of HHS, not Social Security), requested on form HA-501.
  3. Review by the Medicare Appeals Council.
  4. Federal court.

POMS HI 01140.001, Overview of the Appeals Process for IRMAA.

A "predetermination" notice is not a decision

Some people first get a notice of planned action. It has no appeal rights because nothing has been decided yet. If it already shows a problem (a life-changing event, an amended return, the wrong tax year), ask for a new determination now. Social Security must accept an appeal if you insist, but it will tell you an appeal may not be the right step at that stage.

Appeal questions

How do I appeal IRMAA?

File Form SSA-561 (Request for Reconsideration) with Social Security within 60 days of receiving your notice. First check whether a new initial determination applies, which is often quicker and gets the same result.

My IRMAA appeal was denied. What now?

You can request a hearing before an administrative law judge at the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals. If the reason was a non-qualifying event (such as a Roth conversion or capital gain), the decision is unlikely to change, because the law limits newer-year requests to the listed life-changing events.

Can an amended return lower my IRMAA?

Yes, without any life-changing event, if it lowers the MAGI for the year Social Security used. Bring the amended return and the IRS receipt letter, or a transcript. Social Security will use it even if it raises your IRMAA.

Related