Two-Year Lookback
Independent site, not affiliated with any government agency. Figures come from CMS and SSA publications, cited on each page.

Roth conversions and IRMAA: how much can you convert?

Every dollar you convert from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA counts in AGI, so it raises MAGI for that year. Two years later, that MAGI sets your Medicare premiums. A conversion made by December 31, 2026 is measured against the 2028 IRMAA lines, which CMS will not publish until the fall of 2027.

This page is about the premium effect only. Whether a conversion makes sense also depends on your tax brackets now and later, which this site does not model.

Worked example: a couple converting in 2026

A married couple, both on Medicare, file jointly. Without a conversion their 2026 MAGI is $180,000 (pensions, the taxable part of Social Security, interest). The projected first 2028 joint line is $232,000 at 3.7% inflation for the months not yet published (projection method).

2028 surcharge for the couple, by size of 2026 conversion (projected lines, 2027 dollar amounts)
Conversion2026 MAGI2028 bracketSurcharge for both, per year
$0$180,000None$0.00
$52,000$232,000None$0.00
$52,001$232,0011st$2,378.40
$100,000$280,0001st$2,378.40
$114,000$294,0001st$2,378.40
$114,001$294,0012nd$5,978.40

What the table shows:

  1. $52,000 is the free amount. Up to that conversion, the couple stays under the first line and pays no surcharge.
  2. Crossing a line costs the whole step at once. One dollar over, and the couple pays $2,378.40 for 2028.
  3. Once over a line, the rest of that bracket costs nothing extra. A $100,000 conversion costs the same $2,378.40 as a $52,001 one, and so does converting up to $114,000 (MAGI of $294,000). The next dollar moves them to the 2nd bracket at $5,978.40.

The numbers use the 2027 surcharge amounts because the 2028 amounts are not set yet; they usually rise each year.

Leave a margin

The 2028 lines depend on inflation through August 2027. If prices rise 2% a year for the rest of that period instead of 3.7%, the first joint line would be $230,000 rather than $232,000. A conversion that lands exactly on the 3.7% line would then be $2,000 over. Staying a few thousand dollars below a projected line, or at or below the 2027 line ($224,000 joint), covers that risk.

Other things that can push 2026 MAGI higher than you planned: year-end mutual fund capital gain distributions, required minimum distributions, and tax-exempt interest, which counts for IRMAA even though it is not taxed.

The two-year lag works in both directions

  • Conversions at 63 and 64 count. Your first year on Medicare at 65 uses your income from age 63.
  • A conversion cannot be undone for IRMAA. Social Security lists an IRA conversion as a non-qualifying event, so Form SSA-44 will not remove a surcharge it caused (POMS HI 01120.005).
  • The surcharge lasts one year per conversion year. A large conversion in 2026 affects 2028 premiums only; 2029 depends on 2027 income.

Roth conversion questions

Does a Roth conversion count toward IRMAA?

Yes. The converted amount is included in AGI, and IRMAA uses AGI plus tax-exempt interest.

Do qualified Roth withdrawals count toward IRMAA?

Qualified Roth IRA distributions are not included in AGI (IRS Publication 590-B), so they do not raise MAGI for IRMAA. That is one reason people convert before or early in retirement.

Is it ever worth crossing an IRMAA line?

Sometimes. A one-year surcharge of about $1,190 per person (1st bracket, 2027 amounts) can be small next to the tax saved by converting at a lower rate. Compare the surcharge from the calculator with your tax estimate before deciding.

Related